Obertan in Forest loan move?

Making loan switch?

Making loan switch?

One of the things that most of us can agree on is that certain players have not made the grade as far as challenging for the first team. The likes of Mike Williamson, Dan Gosling and Romain Amalfitano simply have not been good enough in terms of providing proper competition for places in our squad. With Amalfitano out on loan to French side Dijon, it would appear that another of our disappointing fringe players is to be sent out on loan, with reports that Gabriel Obertan is set to make a loan switch to Championship side Nottingham Forest.

Since making his 3 million pound transfer from Manchester United to Newcastle United in the summer of 2011, Gabriel Obertan has failed to impress either the Newcastle fans, or Alan Pardew in his attempt to nail down a first team spot. According to Tutto Mercato, Nottingham Forest wanted to take the former Bordeaux player to the Championship club over the summer but a move did not materialise, but that they are very interested in taking him on a temporary basis; something I think Newcastle manager Alan Pardew would be more than open to, despite his small squad.

I’ve spoken a lot about how important short-term loan deals can not only aid the development of the player in question, but can increase competition for places in the squad when these players return. With the likes of Sammy Ameobi, Curtis Good and Paul Dummett all enjoying successful loan spells last season, and with each of these players having played some part in Newcastle’s first team, Obertan could be heading into any possible loan deal full of hope that he will return a much more confident player.

Personally, I don’t think Obertan is of the standard to make it with the Newcastle United first team, but a successful loan spell could turn him into a decent squad player, something we are in desperate need of.

What are your thoughts on Obertan, the loan system, and some of our other fringe players? I’d like to hear your views, and I will answer most, if not all comments.

Bring on the comments people!



  1. I think Obertan is a confidence player and a spell in the Championship could do him the world of good. Of course it could back fire if he flops there as his confidence will be completely shot but I actually think he would be OK for a team like Forest.


    1. I think you could be right Martoon. While I don’t think he’ll ever be a prominent starter for us, I think he could be a very useful squad player. As Jail rightly pointed out earlier, we only have to look at the development of Routledge at Swansea to see how players can develop under certain coaches and at certain ages.

      A good spell there could see him be a good bench player as I think he has some level of talent.


  2. not so sure myself tbh !
    my view is he was in manu when they hardly lost any games and he was not great there when his confidence should have been sky high !

    and when with us he plays great against foreign teams but not in the prem !

    i would say he and us would be happier if he was in the french league and seeing as we stole many of there players maybe we should give them one back as a thank you.


What do you think? Leave a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s