Do New Signings Mark a Change in Direction for NUFC?

Former Ajax Captain

Former Ajax Captain

Touted for big things

Touted for big things

There you have it, the World Cup is sadly over, and I think few could have many complaints about the eventual winners. Germany were by far the best team in the tournament, combining ruthless efficiency with some moments of sheer class to deservedly win the most coveted prize in world football. Now that the World Cup is over, and we are now only 32 days away from the new Premier League season, I thought it appropriate to give my views on Newcastle United’s summer transfer business thus far and form some conclusions where, as things stand, does this leave the club going forward into the new season.

To say that Newcastle United’s transfer business was underwhelming prior to the recent acquisitions of former Ajax man, Siem de Jong, and current France International Remy Cabella, is an understatement. Having only signed Jack Colback on a free from the unwashed, and securing the services of talented, yet unproven, Spanish kid Ayoze Perez, one could be forgiven for thinking it would be more of the same as Newcastle United would flatter to deceive and go into the new season with a grossly inadequate squad.

However, in recent days, the club has taken rather pro-active steps to secure the services of a couple of very capable players which some have taken to social media to claim as an act of intent that Mike Ashley does indeed want to push the club forward in the right direction. While I must admit that I do agree with the sentiment that these two players are indeed quite capable, unless many more signings are finalised between now and the end of the transfer window, it will be more akin to maintaining the status quo than any semblance of squad building.

Before I get accused of being cynical, or negative, let me back up my point of view. From 25-man squad that was named for the start of last season we are currently 6 players lighter; Shola Ameobi, Dan Gosling, James Tavernier, Yohan Cabaye, Loic Remy and Mathieu Debuchy (all but confirmed). While some would argue that Shola Ameobi, Dan Gosling and James Tavernier are not great losses (especially since the latter spent the whole season away from the club on loan) it still is worth mentioning that Shola made 28 appearances in all competitions last season while Dan Gosling was consistently in our match-day squads, making 10 appearances in all competitions. Add those two to the monumental losses felt by the departure of Cabaye, the inevitable departure of Debuchy and the expiration of Loic Remy’s loan spell, then we were left with very sizeable holes left in our squad that needed to be addressed.

For argument’s sake, let’s say De Jong fills the hole left by Remy, Cabella fills the hole left by Cabaye, the reported signing of Janmaat fills the hole left by the outgoing Debuchy, Perez fills the hole left by Shola and Colback fills the hole left by Gosling* then surely a case can be made that the signings that have been made are solely replacements for the players we have let go? In fact, the positivity that has been spun on social media has no basis because there has been no actual squad building. In order to build a squad that is better than the one before, you do not replace your building blocks with other building blocks, you build on the building blocks you already have with more building blocks. If you keep switching like-for-like then you will never get anywhere. You will simply stay where you are.

(*A lot of these players are not like-for-like signings as they play somewhat different positions/roles)

This is the crux of the issue I’m afraid. We are standing still.  I said at the start of last season that we were at least 5/6 players short of a squad that could realistically push the top 6 teams, and that was shown to be the case in the second half of last season. Therefore, I will echo those sentiments this time around. We are at least 5/6 players short of a squad who can realistically challenge the top 8 teams in the Premier League.

It must also be said that everything that has been aforementioned is on the pretence that we do not sell any more players. If any more players are let go, we need to sign their replacements and then sign another 5/6 players on top of that – this is with the expected departures of Hatem Ben Arfa and Yanga Mapou M’biwa in mind.

While I am glad that we have replaced quality players such as Loic Remy, Yohan Cabaye and Mathieu Debuchy with potentially quality players in Siem de Jong, Remy Cabella and Daryl Janmaat (still to be confirmed), this does not satisfy me as there has been nothing in the way of actual progress.

I am cynical when it comes to Newcastle United. I am negative when it comes to Mike Ashley. I am frustrated when it comes to Alan Pardew. But don’t I have good reason to be? So while Pardew is patting himself on the back for bringing a few players in, Newcastle United are still a long way short of where they need to be going into next season. Unfortunately, I fear they have done enough to flog those remaining season-tickets, and get the happy clappers back on board to fill up the stadium for the visit of reigning champions Manchester City on the opening day of the season. To say this fact disappoints me is an understatement.




  1. Who can argue with that? Ashley has to go a long way yet to proving he really has ambition for this football club. I, for one, seriously doubt that is the case.


  2. Like for like as you call it, is actually selling for profit and buying cheaper (and possibly poorer) replacements.
    It’s been a business plan that Ashley has employed since day one.
    A plan that is about making money.
    Retaining membership in the PL, with mid table mediocrity the only ambition.
    thought everyone had figured this out by now.


  3. I don’t necessarily disagree with the building blocks theory, however the replacements are people who want to play for Newcastle – Remy didn’t, Cabaye didn’t, Debuchy doesn’t with Gosling and Ameobi clearly not good enough!
    I’m slightly disappointed we haven’t shipped more out, Marveaux, Obertan, M’biwa, senior players on large wages who consistently fail to perform – we have some young exciting players coming through, isn’t it time we gave them a bit of a chance to establish themselves, let them become the next building blocks – Young Armstrong for instance, had a few run outs last season surely now’s the opportunity to start him alongside a more experienced forward be it Cisse, De Jong?

    Building blocks – Have a strong base and build upon that for the future: Surely the future lies with our young, hopefully English (or even better, local) youths as does the future of the whole of English Football !


    1. Good sentiments Bosh but judging by the World Cup, English football doesn’t have much of a future. Foreign performers leave our players standing for skills, application and desire – that’s why there are hundreds in the PL Allied to ridiculously over-inflated prices for home grown players and it’s only going to get worse I fear.


      1. Fair point and I’m not sure how to overcome it? The main problem is, as I see it, that managers are scared to blood the youngsters for fear of losing and as such they’re left to the cups – This appears to be our strategy and as such we don’t get far, but we have to start somewhere for the players to develop and loaning to lower league clubs doesn’t appear to work, look how many promising youngsters have moved on, Tavernier being the latest.
        Perhaps a bit of honesty from the Management and club hierarchy as to what strategy they are aiming to follow!!

        Like you I fear for our National game, having travelled to previous world cups and Euro campaigns I’m afraid to say that I couldn’t dredge up much, if any, enthusiasm for this latest one, and having seen the vastly superior performances of some of the smaller teams, and heard Nevilles comments about not changing our game I can only see it getting worse!


  4. Great article, totally agree with you, keep your foundation and build on it, shame Ashley isn’t a very good builder, he is however a very good demolition man. So many are blinded by Ashley or prefer to stick their heads in the sand rather than look at the squad, the last seven years and what has gone on before at Newcastle United under this man. So many seem to think that if you are a sceptic it’s because you don’t love the club, a lot of us are sceptical because of the proof that has been put in front of us all of which is still going on. I’ve said before that I would of loved Ashley to prove me wrong but he’s had seven years to do that, and unfortunately is still proving me right.

    Do we now have to kiss Ashleys arse because he bought a couple of players? I think not, proof is in the pudding and Ashley obviously eats plenty of them


  5. I totally agree with Last post.
    I for one am not at all convinced that Ashley has changed his approach regarding the purse strings. all he has done is used the Debuchy money to bring in 2 other players.
    Why the hell doea,nt he dip into the sky money and show some real ambition.


What do you think? Leave a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s